Are Child Labor Laws Ruining this Country…?



…and further, are they hurting the world? Even Keynesian Kook Krugman pointed out several years ago that in other, less civilized countries, labor laws don’t magically bring children to school and bring an end to poverty – instead, honest factory work is replaced with crime on the streets.

But the subject is this country, and I do share, with our friend Mr. Ron Swanson, that child labor laws are ruining this country. We have this idea that if it weren’t for child labor laws all children would be working in coal mines for twenty cents a day, and I think such a notion in our modern times, in the United States, is certainly unreasonable.

The biggest part of liberty – economic and personal liberty – is choice. Surely there is a great segment of students who aren’t taking school seriously and are nothing more – if you allow me to phrase it in such a way – a burden on the system. If these children would rather be working, doing reasonable jobs for reasonable pay at a reasonable age, I don’t think it is our place – and certainly isn’t government’s place – to object.

And further, working that is co-operative with school (such as during summers) is difficult to do legally before sixteen, but many kids would like to work before that time, say at age 13, 14, or 15. Of course, this would be up to the parents and the child, as it should be.

Of course I don’t think it should be entirely unregulated, but children should have the opportunity to work if they wish, especially if there is a need within the household. If not, no big deal either.

But this is quite impossible, thanks to a government which always likes to think it knows best for everyone.

Comments, welcome, as always.



One thought on “Are Child Labor Laws Ruining this Country…?”

  1. That’s an interesting point that I’ve honestly never thought of before. The idea behind Child Labor Laws is that it will prevent parents from FORCING their kids to work just to exploit them, but it does make things difficult for children under sixteen who actually NEED jobs, especially the ones who need it because their families have difficulty meeting financial needs. I believe it also assists in making younger generations much more irresponsible. Getting a job teaches someone how to work with others, follow rules, the value of money and how to save it or spend it responsibly, and just to be responsible in general by simply doing what you’re told when you’re told to do it. The problem is, it isn’t teaching kids that until well past a time when they should have learned it. That’s one of the worst consequences, in my opinion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s